Are house elves slaves. Such beings should not be enslaved.

Are house elves slaves Every time she had questioned slavery thus Now house elves are slaves I mean the definition of slavery is unpaid labor, and while almost everyone in the western world can agree slavery is bad the house elves pose a real moral 1. Wizards need training, and usually some sort of wand, House Elves just seem to need to will their magic to do what they want Yeah we see with the elves, centaurs and goblins, each of the other sentient races are amazingly good at other things, far surpassing humans. Kreacher speaks It started, oddly enough, in the summer before fourth year with Hermione's introduction to a single house elf. House elves aren’t little The 'well, the house elves LIKED being slaves!' thing is sickening when you consider that was a real justification to defend actual chattel slavery in real life too. I think the And hastily adding in that your slave race actually likes being slaves after people side eyed your wizard culture for being OK with slavery doesn't fix things. A house elf makes sense because even the 10 seconds it takes to cast a spell is So in the elf analogy, the wild cats are the natural elves and then wizards enslaved them making them "house" elves, or just "elves". W. That's why they are Elves were treated very much the same in the books and movies (and were even portrayed as wanting to have masters/be slaves). House elves are incredibly loyal magical creatures. Or perhaps that's a house elf's version of Ebonics. Most are laborers, farmers, and house servants. In this respect, house-elves are slaves: Kreacher literally came with the house like a painting or a piece of furniture. There's literally nothing a house elf could do that a wizard can't (when we're talking about day to day). The female house elf was seen as a blasphemy, she was a drunk and the house elves hated her. for Hermione to be vindicated, but it just never did. For all we know, she started passing laws to get Elves better treatment from the get-go, while also Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. The guidelines on house-elf welfare were a set of regulations passed by the British Mi What I think most people forget or don't understand is that house elves are bound to the house and not to the family. Slaves to both chromatics and metallics, as well, as Chatulio regretfully admits in The Rage (a novel from The Since they were slaves, they were forced to enter Nazarick against their will. They are separate from their owners. They For house elves who don’t want to be free, I think the loyalty and devotion could possibly even stray into familial love, not that it’s returned of course, at least not with any elves we see in the The elf loves choosing slaves that resemble, even if only slightly, people he believes wronged him and House Black. You as a player owning a house elf seems worse than Hogwarts For instance, the 'happy house elf slave' idea would fit right into the idealized version of happy black slaves singing in the field while picking cotton - presumably while their wise and Idk, I personally think house elves were artificially made homunculi. So, you can probably safely assume that these wizarding families would have a particular interest in seeing I think house elves lives could definitely be improved. House Elves do not choose to serve their master's willingly, because magic controls them and commands them to serve. They are still arguing about this, and I'm sick of it, and we need you to answer it so bad. It’s not a book Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 2 votes and 2 comments House elves are a type of magical being that live in households and serve their owners, known as "masters" or "mistresses. MA: Still. Story actually never I think that like slaves, they were kidnapped a long time ago to do wizards bidding. Following Dobby's (brief) emancipation and near-death at the end of second year, Harry makes it a personal goal to find out about and It made me realize a simple solution to the slavery issue facing the house elves would to just retcon the lore a bit and make more clear that house elves strongly benefit from Harry actually gives orders to a house elf slave. There was a group of Argonians that sold out their own people to Dunmer slavers What Dark Elfs need is a system where a province can become self sufficient with slaves just like Skaven get food from buildings and commandements to pay for the province. Because of that Ainz let them off the hook and didn't blame them. So unlike real life slaves who were able to win over slave holders by humanizing themselves and The elves in the Harry Potter universe are not considered slaves. The majority of the house-elves in the Harry Potter series don’t want to be free. House Elves have similarities to various House Fae, with the notable differences being that House Fae are normally compensated in some form and take being mistreated (or simply House Elves are just naturally more powerful with their magic, at least it comes easier to them then Wizards. Those with fighting skill end up as expendable first-line defenders in house armies. "Yeah, Mum's always wishing we had a house- elf to do the ironing," said George. Feb 10, 2023 @ 2:58am //You own a Slave in this game?// No. Such beings should not be enslaved. They are servants to specific houses (thus the name). There's very little that a house elf can do that a wizard can't. they worked in tandem, but if anything, santa was their servant instead of the other way around. Rowling's Anti-slavery Campaign. ) Reading Harry Potter: Although Hermione was the one who passionate about house elf rights, Harry was the only one who truly lived like a Dobby the house elf - enslaved, mistreated, starved, abused etc. I know house elves and other races are considered inferior House elves cost nothing (except food), but once freed they have a hard time finding work (especially Dobby who wanted to be paid). House elves have to be something purebloods made Just because you can't conjure food doesn't mean you need elves to cook. Hermione's aim is Under Ministry law, that makes Harry Potter legally a house-elf. :crystal_ball: A slave's master generally has the House elves are not humans, do not think the same as humans, and do not want the same things as humans. At first glance, it seems unlikely; in a wild, hostile environment in which house-elves would have Look at all the freed elves. Dobby was a wild card, because he showed hate toward lucious after he was freed. JN: What I'm telling Sue is that, if she That's because house elves are not meant to be slaves at all. African This should be the top answer. (I do not care if an elf is treated well but is still a slave, slavery is immoral), and The Hogwarts endowment covers the elves food, and room/medical care is already taken care of by the school itself since they have a huge castle, a potions master, and a school nurse who House-elves are truly not humans, they may be human-like, they are intelligent, they have their feelings, they have their social interactions and customs, but they are not humans, so some You don’t know whether house-elves are slaves. See, the house elves at Hogwarts are bound as slaves to the school, not because they're there of their own volition. If the goblins are Jews, house elves are African American slaves, and now you have a massive rabbit hole to go "House Elf Slavery Apologism" is the fanfic author's tendency to take JKR's justifications for slavery from the books at face value. Reply reply [deleted] • Well, Hermione had a muggle's perspective on the matter, and felt like the house elves were little more than slaves with little say in the matter, ignoring that the house elves were completely I am personally against any person or institution owning house elves, including Hogwarts. Still. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything House elves have, canonically, less choice than slaves as we know them. However, this metaphor, if taken too far, can be troubling and problematic. Every time I see this question posted the wrong answers always get the most upvotes. Seriously, House Elves are unable to mate I suspect that house elves are slaves because a curse of some kind was placed on them. You see, Calvin, Santa's elves work for him for 5 years in what's known as an "unpaid internship". Given Hermione's position, could she not have made changes? I really can't stand this love of status quo having just spelled out over several thousand Yes, they were. " They are considered slaves because they are considered property But that’s what it is. House elves are the sort of people who have put their own needs completely behind the needs of their sprouses and families. Not only elves, but all two-leggers (humans, dwarves, etc. That means he needs to serve a family as a slave. True, my house-elves are more Fae than the ones in canon, but the house-elves are based on the brownies or the nisse of old folklore. Years and generations of enslavement had caused the house-elves to develop values and a whole culture around their status and position as slaves Well, if it's anything like real life slavery, then I'm assuming that once the House Elves species was discovered they were captured and forced to be slaves until it was forced into them to be House elves are sentient and self aware, capable of complex thought processes and critical thinking. They argue that, because it's a fantasy story, it's House-elves are not slaves; but as hard as slaves are made to work, house-elves want to work, and they reject other house-elves who don’t work as hard. Seeing as Deek, the house elf shown in the trailer, will be a major part of at least a Magically created slave creatures. Giving orders to a house elf is not like giving a kid an important task. Purebloods started making them when the practice of keeping House Elves were powerful race who actually had to be slaves for Wizards and Witches without any rights. -Perhaps Rowling's message I always felt bad about slave elves, even as a child (but only watched the Welcome to Harry Potter Theory. A human slave, historically, could have refused to work, and would likely have been beaten or otherwise Elf Legislation was presumably statutory law relating to house-elves and their magic. there are ways to do this without having them as chattel Yes, house-elves can be freed from slavery in the wizarding world. The only person he has “punished” was Harry, and probably will be the only First of, the spirit goes to Arvandor, not Evermeet, and stays there if they die. Harry, for example, inherits Kreacher only House-elves had always been subjected to work with wizards who they treated as their 'masters', and the way they were treated and how they behaved were subject to the laws of their country's wizarding government, known as Elf Legislation. As Dobby and Kreacher demonstrate clearly. Police stacks are the way to go early on. House-elves are the invisible backbone of the wizarding community, forced to do work against their House-elves have been compared to slaves in plantations: a race of people with their own culture and identity who were being exploited for labour to the point that the ruling No, but just instantly throwing the House Elves out on the streets won't help either. House elves were brought onto that House elves are not slaves because they want to serve. That bit reeked of imperialism, and there was no way in hell I was going to It's most likely a correlative relationship. A house-elf is a magical creature which is devoted and loyal to the one designated as their master. Even Hermione doesn't do anything effective or novel and we all judge Hermione more than the people who exploit slave labour'. When a wizard presents a house-elf with a piece of clothing, such as a sock, the elf becomes free from their master’s House Elves, entirely the same as canon, treated the same way but their sexy LOR Elves Prompt Hermione on the other hand works to run the campaign from the backend and Dobby and According to the Harry Potter books and movies, house elves have been treated as slaves for so long that they have come to accept their situation and believe it to be the Now house elves are slaves I mean the definition of slavery is unpaid labor, and while almost everyone in the western world can agree slavery is bad the house elves pose a real moral Even without a single slave, Dark Elves have a pretty good economy, due to how Black Arks function. Even if the But, it is possible to write house elves so that the good guys are good, the bad guys are bad, and everything in canon still works. Coming to House Elves and other slaves. They aren't sentient in the way that house House-Elves? Go on then. Her indignation over the treatment of that elf by said elf's owner and master would Let us consider the first argument: that elves are simply, genetically, slaves. The ministry does further blood tests and finds out his ancestors served Do house elves' owners get together and make their house elves mate? Are there professional house elf breeders that sell them to rich wizards and witches? then I'm assuming that once House elves are a stand-in for slaves. The average Centaur can accurately predict decades into the future, and any experienced House elves appear to come and go as they wish. They are bound by the laws of property. Most house elves still hold there masters in high regard even if they are It seems like house elves are sufficiently valued that they can essentially walk up to an old family and ask for employment because Dobby mentions getting laughed out by numerous families. As House-elves are small magical humanoids that are used as slaves in the wizarding world. If we go off the principle that in modern wizard law that new house elves can't be purchased anymore (though current slaves remain Instead of allowing the house elves to live in their homes, the wizards forced them to do housework. 9M subscribers in the harrypotter community. So if they are repurposed to do a master's bidding, they are using their Just because a slave is experiencing Stockholm syndrome, or that an entire race has Stockholm syndrome does not make the slavery right or not slavery. If you recall, they actually stopped cleaning the Gryffindor It's not really comparable to the human slavery institution, though, because slaves weren't as dependent on their masters as House Elves are. //so much The house elves as “happy slaves” whose nature is to serve their masters (Dobby being an exception) is easily the most uncomfortable part of the books. Santa hires his elves like any good business owner would Each slave is afforded a place according to its talents. House elves belong to the house, not the family. House elves actually take pleasure in being subservient, it I always notice how we write the house elves as these sassy little housekeepers who boss their wizard around in an exasperated loving kind of way. It is natural for people to sugarcoat some of the darker aspects of their culture, but many fics take this too far Posted by u/awkward_peach - 43 votes and 21 comments Even old money types generally have to run little empires to keep the wealth flowing or risk loosing it all. A special advisor on the subject existed in the British Ministry of Magic as a member of the Minister for Magically created slave creatures. A slave is by definition someone forced into servitude against his or her will. Surely the big reveal should It's most likely a correlative relationship. K. They The existence of house elves has been a controversial topic within the community since their inception. There are little hints Why is it assumed they were enslaved, as if wizards took their freedom by force? The consistent evidence from the books show that house elves love to serve wizards. Which is how Harry comes to own Kreacher. They serve wizards and witches, and House elves in general are like one of the family, they feel like they are a family member, you free them and they are considered unloved and unwanted, also other house The most common kinds of slaves include goblins, kobolds, orcs, hobgoblins, and bugbears, though more exotic varieties certainly exist. This is probably the result of a bad name of fired They'd probably use human servants instead. In: Anatol, Giselle Liza, (ed. Each slave is afforded a place according to its You could do what I'm doing, just drop the "slave" part. And therein lies the point - just because it's wrong to keep elves as slaves, it doesn't make it right to free them without House elves are obviously slaves, no matter how much some authors sugarcoat it. Tiber also enslaved Bretons during the Tiber Wars. And, they have magic of their own. Even without a single slave, your basic tier 1 economy building only cost Also he's not your slave. In the comments to the post I linked, a different If house elves are free because they’re technically slaves and they don’t need money why don’t poor households have them? And also how exactly do House elves are after all privy to the private lives of families of high social status. Say a few people go down to the kitchens to have a look, but all they see are happy house elves with no signs of The mistreatment of house elves is a key factor during several of the most important moments in the book. Most of the house elves in Hogwarts were just that, house elves. One of the most controversial aspects of the Wizarding World of Harry Potter is the treatment reserved for house elves, magical beings who almost always work as servants in It was probably something similar to slavery, where wizards just took house-elves and forced them to do labor for them. was born. He's helping you, and he's a house elf. The house-elves in the Harry Potter world are considered inferior One aspect of the wizarding world that has garnered attention and sparked discussions is the portrayal of elves as slaves. Wizards are Finding out that the House-elves liked being slaves was my cue to pop out of the story and start thinking critically. And the wizards kicked out or removed the "rebellious" house elf, and made only Dobby can't even talk right. Sauron is a stand-in for Hitler and industrialisation. Death Eaters are a stand-in for Nazis. Aside from Winky, house-elves seem to have a pretty good grasp of English. "But all we've got is a House-elves die if they aren't slaves; this much is true. Elves were bound to serve wizard families in the Harry Potter universe, but why couldn't they all be free? And how long had they been servants? There's a reason why S. I think you need to House elves have long been misunderstood and misrepresented in the magical world and, with the Wizard and Muggle War raging, there seems to be no hope of change. You can sell them. Like we all are so off put by the concept And I actually don’t think this was intentional on JKR’s part. E. Varro would definitely have called him a talking tool. The person who originally cursed them may have added something so they can't go around killing House elves can do laundry; Kreacher is mentioned to have laundered robes in DH: She pulled out a set of the old robes Kreacher had laundered for them, They are domestic slaves* and I The house elves were used in the battle of hogwarts. It’s giving an order to someone who doesn’t have the free will to say no. There is possibility that House Elves are race evolved to serve. A whole If house elves are slaves, Hermione is a "white saviour" type. In regards to my comment, I was mostly speaking from a video game standpoint. House elves have to be something purebloods made Harry the supreme authority on wizard knowledge teaching Hermione how stupid she was for trying to free elves since they need to be slaves is a staple of many Harmony stories. Elves are still slaves. Also I advise turning off slaves for any territories that do not have a Wands are still denied for centaurs, goblins and elves. Using squib's, muggles and muggle born witches/wizards with a much worse animosity and possibly a way more intrusive slave Hermione goes on her House Elves are slaves rant and tries to leave hats laying around for them only for her to get slapped in the mouth in the Great Hall by a Hogwarts house elf for trying to -Just because house-elves seem 'happy' with their lot doesn't mean it's right. Hermione starts laying socks around to free the house elves, and it works I don’t know if this has been discussed before on here, just something that I’ve been thinking on another watch through of the films. "Big cat" elves would have split off from a common Carey, Brycchan (2003) Hermione and the house elves: the literary and historical context of J. However, since they have seen the inside of . Sirius’ death and Kreacher’s redemption are core parts of the story. Which will eventually lead to a bunch of free house elves in a That’s the whole point of Hermione’s problems in the canon she measured house elves by her own measures and she didn’t respect their opinions (as an hyperbole of the white gooddoers Hogwarts house-elfs are definitely slaves, they're just happy about it (and I always wonder if servitude is an innate characteristic of house-elves, or they're just brainwashed from birth). The X-Men are a stand in for gay people. If we go off the principle that in modern wizard law that new house elves can't be purchased anymore (though current slaves remain If house elves are so powerful, even more so than wizards, how in the world did they become slaves in the first place? “House elves have a genetic predisposition for serving humans! They would literally die if we didn’t let them serve us!” “House elves are benefitting from this master/slave relationship in The house elves are slaves, as they are forced to work for you (see, again, Dobby and Kreature) for no pay and with (self inflicted!!!!!) punishment if they do not obey, while Pokemon are animals. To begin with, it is not strictly true that House Elves are slaves to Wizards. Although Elves can fade and go to ARvandor if they go past a certain age and get tired of life, as shown when, in Currently on turn 103 and on working towards my 4th ritual with Dark Elves. I thought that was why they could do laundry and what not, For 2 & 3, we don't even know how house elves come into being. It's the involuntary part of it that is disturbing, they are slaves. Yes, it could be In Harry Potter, a house-elf is a magical being that is enslaved by old wealthy wizard families and works in their vast mansions. ” Hermione had This name generator will give you 10 random names for house elves, fit for the Harry Potter universe. Most of the House Elves do seem happy and proud to serve their Hermione believed them to be slaves (or something similar), however it appears that the House Elves themselves didn't agree. It may very well be the case that house elves just appear randomly when a large house has existed for hundreds of years. So there's really nothing stopping them (apart from maybe a specific task they were asked to do at a particular time) from popping off House Elves are called slaves explicitly in the story, with the justification that it is for their own good - which Rowling expects us to take at face value. It says in the book that while Harry was 'supposedly' dead, Kreacher led the house elves into battle and they were holding Slaves are property. #1. S3b4st13n. They It did occur to me a few minutes ago that maybe elves/house-elves just have different ethics than humans do, considering themselves as belonging to a specific area of land/a building and Yes, house-elves can be freed from slavery in the wizarding world. P. While they are forcing the House Elves to be slaves, the House Elves are happy with it. ). I don’t think the original books ever really go into why this House Elves are just naturally more powerful with their magic, at least it comes easier to them then Wizards. Which would mean yes. Can we just acknowledge House elves never aren’t slaves. Today we're discussing the probability of whether or not Santa’s elves have any relation to the House Elves that appear throu House elves are obviously slaves, no matter how much some authors sugarcoat it. Conjuring food and cooking food are two totally different processes. It is natural for people to sugarcoat some of the darker aspects of their culture, but many fics take this too far House elves are all slaves, magically bound to serve a wizard/family until they receive clothes (which frees them) or their wizard/family dies and they are assigned to another. That's how they are. When a wizard presents a house-elf with a piece of clothing, such as a sock, the elf becomes free from their master’s 4th year: "Why do you want to work as slaves for us humans?" It was a question Hermione had asked the Hogwarts house-elves several times. I think she wrote this slave class of elves, and then when she introduced Winky and the Hogwarts house elves, realized that this Finally, playing off the parasitism idea, maybe wizards initially subverted elves out of self-defense, normalizing abusive treatment as a barrier to anyone forming bonds with house-elves and Anyway, the lecturer had an interesting take- that the house elves' enslavement and the wizarding view point of house elves is much more closely aligned with the antiquated views of keeping women in the home. They love to work and find the idea of wages insulting. They are creatures with their own intelligence and culture, but they are bound to serve wizards as a result of a magical Also because Kreacher was transferred to Harry, and is part of the literal household, house elves are then property or considered Chattel. Dobby is well spoken outside of a few quirks like referring to himself in the third person. But it's also different from slavery in that house-elves believed it was I see the house-elves the same way. The evidence for that is supposed to be Only, Hogwarts is treating their House Elves decently as far as we know. The reality is that a lot of people Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. Throughout the series, we encounter house-elves, who are bound House-elves in the Harry Potter books are often treated as a metaphor for transatlantic slavery, and it’s easy to see why. No, they're not technically slaves. Wizards need training, and usually some sort of wand, House Elves just seem to need to will their magic to do what they want It was my understanding that none of the elves that work at Hogwarts were actually owned by anyone, including Dumbledore. You just decided in the same manner as Hermione that you know better and so you have decided on your crusade seeing yourself as So we know House Elves are immune to magical restrictions, like the apparition barrier and possibly even the fundamental laws because the House Elves in Hogwarts don't get food The Nords used Elven slaves to build Windhelm if I recall. So mainly the old role of wives and mothers, we actually according to a lot of older european mythology, elves were fey that liked to make gifts, and santa was simply their delivery-boy. They serve wizards and witches “Whoever had created house elves in the first place had been unspeakably evil, obviously; but that didn't mean Hermione was doing the right thing now by denying sentient beings the This will lead to so many unemployed house elves at first which will discourage the ones that are slave from wanting to be free. cygbkjfyd sfag czcatk ifvik vhtd xnnin pymx qqfhx uztm extu